Sunday, 17 January 2016

The Benefit They're Real Push-up Liner


I am sure you are all aware that I have my brows done at Benefit and I am a big lover of their 'They're Real' Mascara.  However, I generally don't buy a lot of their products as theres other brands that I love and rate more.  However, I recently caved and thought it was time I tried their 'They're Real' push-up liner since I love the mascara and lash primer so much and Boots was sold out of my usual Collection Liquid Liner! 

The liner boasts an 'AccuFlex' tip that guarantees an easy and smooth, lash-hugging application.  The liner itself comes in gel formula and twists upwards to apply like a pen.  I have been a big fan of gel eyeliners in the past, especially the likes of AVON SuperShock Gel Eyeliner Pencil (£4.00) which I think is an excellent drugstore dupe of Urban Decay's 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil (£15.50).  I find the ease of use of gel liners much smoother than kohl liners or liquid formulas.  Upon first use of this eyeliner, I found it quite strange to adjust to as I wasn't sure how much product was required or how far to twist to get enough product at the tip. 



The AccuFlex tip definitely provides the user with a precise and easy application and I love that about this eye liner.  I think the curved edge provides a perfect wing to the eye and the concept behind this is genius!  However, I couldn't get along with the gel formula as I found it clumped together when first applying it to the skin making the strokes uneven. This disappointed me slightly as for £18.50, I expected much more from Benefit.  The matte black pigment wasn't quite as intense as the colour of my Collection Fast Stroke Eye Liner, however, I don't see that as a massive influence when buying eye liners.  Benefit also claim that the "formula is waterproof and won't smudge, budge or dry out for 24 hours", I found this to be true once set, however, the eyeliner does smudge after initial application and leaves an unwanted black residue on the eyes when removing (I think this is something that comes with gel formulas).  


So the question is, would I use Benefit's They're Real Push-Up Liner over my much loved Collection Fast Stroke Eyeliner?  The answer is simply, no.  Throughout using this liner, I found myself applying my Collection eyeliner on top of it for a more intense colour and I got continuously frustrated with the fact that the formula kept smudging unlike my Collection liner which sets almost instantly and does not budge!  That said, I love the tip and ease of application of this liner and the Collection Liner requires you to have a much more steady hand when applying and doesn't give you the same effect wing. 

I think it is down to personal preference but I was slightly let down by Benefit's formula here!

At just £2.99 for the Collection Fast Stroke Liquid formula, I still will not be changing my eye liner! Collection; please do not change the formula of your liquid liner, I simply couldn't live without it!

The Benefit They're Real Push Up Liner is available to buy here!

What do you think of Benefit's They're Real Push-Up Liner?  Do you have a go-to liner that you just couldn't live without?

Let me know in the comments!


4 comments :

  1. Sounds like such a bummer that the color wasn't that intense and that it kept smudging! The worst thing about eyeliners is when they smudge and leave panda eyes :(

    Rae | Love from Berlin

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know! It's such a shame because I was really excited to try this! xxxx

      Delete
  2. I haven't used this one, but read mixed reviews about it. I have oily lids so I hate it when eyeliner smudges. I will definitely skip this one, I wouldn't want to waste my money on it. I love my supercat from soap&glory, it is really pigmented and it lasts for a long time without smudging :) x

    www.elabellaworld.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ohh I've read about Supercat from Soap&Glory! I will be sure to try that one out! Thank you! xxxx

      Delete